Diwaniye logo Diwaniye

Hand: when to draw from the stock and when to take the discard

Most turns in Hand start with one choice: the stock or the face-up discard. What the rules say, worked examples and advice on choosing well.

Published · 4 min read

Hand game artwork

Most turns in Hand start with the same choice: draw from the stock, or take the face-up discard. It looks small, but it shapes the rest of your turn. Here is what the rules say, then advice and worked examples.

What the rules say

These are the rules that matter for this choice:

  • On your turn, you draw from the stock or take the face-up discard, then meld, add to the table, or discard.
  • A taken discard must be used before you can discard another card.
  • The starter receives an extra card and acts before drawing.
  • Keep one card to discard.
  • Available actions and discard choices come from the table.

Two more rules decide how a card can be used. Your first opening needs at least 51 points, or a complete Hand, with groups of 3 to 5 cards. After you open, a single card can be added to a meld on the table, extend a run at the end you choose, or replace the joker in a table meld.

The difference between the two

The two choices are not equal:

  • The stock gives you a card you can’t see before you take it, and nothing is attached to it.
  • The face-up discard is a card you can see before you choose, but it comes with a condition: you must use it before you can discard another card.

So the face-up card is the known card with a condition attached. That turns the choice into one practical question: can I use this card this turn?

Before you open

Until your first opening, your groups stay in your hand, and the way to get cards onto the table is the opening itself. So before you open, the face-up card is most clearly worth taking when it helps you open this turn, for example by completing the group that brings your opening to 51 points or more.

If the face-up card would only help “one day,” the stock is usually the safer choice.

After you open

Once you have opened, the table gives a face-up card more places to go. You can use it in a new group you put down, add it to a meld on the table, extend a run at one of its ends, or use it to replace a joker in a table meld. With more ways to use it, the face-up card deserves a closer look every turn.

The starter’s first turn

The starter receives an extra card and acts before drawing. So the starter’s first move isn’t the choice between the stock and the discard: it’s deciding what to do with the cards already in hand, then discarding. Whatever you discard can become the face-up card the next player considers, so it’s worth thinking about what you let go.

Keep one card to discard

Your turn still ends with a discard, and when you put groups down you keep one card to discard. If you take the face-up card and use it, you still need a different card to throw. Plan for both before you pick it up.

Worked examples

These use group totals only, to keep the counting simple.

Example 1: before opening, the card completes your opening. You hold groups worth 24 and 21 points, 45 in total, plus two cards waiting for a third. The face-up card completes them into a group worth 15 points. That makes 60, so take it, open with all three groups, keep a card and discard it.

Example 2: before opening, the card helps but not enough. The face-up card completes a group, but your groups would still total only 40. You can’t open with that this turn, and a taken discard must be used before you can discard another card. Draw from the stock instead.

Example 3: after opening, the card fits the table. You have opened, and the face-up card continues a run on the table at one end. Take it, add it to that end of the run, and discard a different card.

Example 4: after opening, the card fits nothing. The face-up card fits no group of yours and no meld on the table. Draw from the stock.

Advice for choosing

These are habits, not rules:

  • Ask the question first. Before you reach for the face-up card, ask whether you can use it this turn.
  • “Maybe later” is a reason to leave it. A taken discard must be used before you can discard another card.
  • Watch what others take. A player who takes the face-up card usually has a use for it in mind, which tells you something about their groups.
  • Think about your discard. The card you throw can become the face-up card the next player sees.
  • Keep one card free. You need it for your discard either way.
  • Let the table guide you. Available actions come from the table, so check what it offers.

To plan the opening these choices lead to, read opening with 51 points. For keeping your total down afterwards, see Hand strategy: keeping your total low. The full rules are in Hand card game rules and how to play.

Make your next choice with a plan: play Hand in Diwaniye.